The inner critic often isn’t your enemy. In IFS therapy, it’s seen as a protector part: a part that learnt, usually long ago, that criticising you first was the safest way to keep you from being hurt.
You already know the voice.
“You should have done better.” “Who do you think you are?” “They’re going to find out.”
It shows up before a presentation, after a conversation, at 3am. Many people try to shut it up, argue with it, or drown it out with positive affirmations. And still it comes back.
Why affirmations often don’t stick
I do believe in neuroplasticity. Over time, the brain can reshape itself around what we repeatedly tell it. So affirmations aren’t pointless.
But on their own, I see them as quite a basic, almost pop-psychology approach. A bit like manifesting. They work on the surface, and the inner critic doesn’t live on the surface.
For deep healing, or for really changing behaviour, we need more than new words. We need to understand:
- why we do the things we do
- what keeps the patterns we don’t want going
- the root cause of why we feel the way we do
And then we need to heal that, in a deep way.
That’s why repeating “I am enough” can feel hollow when a part of you is convinced you’re not. The part isn’t listening to the words. It’s still doing the job it learnt to do.
Why fighting it rarely works
If you push against a protector, it usually pushes back harder. From its point of view, the danger is still real.
So instead of asking “how do I get rid of my inner critic?”, IFS asks a different question: what is this part trying to do for me?
In IFS, the inner critic is usually a manager: one of the parts that keeps us functioning and working hard. It isn’t trying to hurt you. It’s trying to keep you from being hurt.
What the inner critic might be protecting
Often, the inner critic learnt its job in childhood. It might have learnt that:
- If you were perfect, you wouldn’t get told off
- If you criticised yourself first, other people’s criticism hurt less
- If you stayed small, you’d still belong
- If you worked harder than everyone else, you’d be safe
In many families, these were sensible lessons. They helped you get by. The trouble is that the part is still doing the same job now, long after the danger has passed.
Underneath, it’s usually guarding something more tender: a younger part of you that still feels not good enough, ashamed or afraid of being left out.
The cultural side of the inner critic
Many cultures come with their own cultural critic. It exists across the board.
I see it a lot in people whose parents migrated. Many of those parents came from real adversity. Moving country meant starting again. Some gave up professional jobs and went into manual labour, working very hard so their children could have a good education and a better life.
That comes from a survival mindset. It makes complete sense. And it can push second-generation children further, sometimes much further, than feels sustainable.
So the inner critic might not only say “you’re not good enough”. It might say:
- “After everything they sacrificed, how can you complain?”
- “You have to do better than everyone else.”
- “What will people say?”
That last one is the title of a book by therapist Sahaj Kaur Kohli, But What Will People Say?, which explores shame, guilt and pressure for children of immigrants. It’s worth a read if this feels familiar.
A cultural critic isn’t a sign that your family got it wrong. It’s often love and fear mixed together, passed down with the best intentions. But it can feel very pressurised to live with.
A gentle exercise
Next time you notice the critic, try this:
- Notice it. “There’s that critical part again.”
- Find it. Where do you feel it in your body? Your chest, jaw, shoulders, stomach?
- Get curious. Ask it, gently: “What are you worried would happen if you stopped?”
- Listen. You might hear something like: “You’d fail.” “They’d reject you.” “You’d let everyone down.”
- Thank it. You don’t have to agree with it. You can simply acknowledge that it’s been working hard.
If you notice you feel angry, frustrated or tired of the critic, that’s another part. That’s okay too. See if it would be willing to step back a little, so you can stay curious.
This isn’t about letting the critic run your life. It’s about building a different relationship with it, so it doesn’t need to shout.
There’s some early research support for this kind of approach. A 2013 trial of an IFS-based programme found that self-compassion improved, and the change was still there a year later. It was a study of people with rheumatoid arthritis, so it’s one small piece of evidence, not the final word.
When you might need more support
Sometimes the inner critic is guarding pain that’s too big to approach alone, such as childhood trauma, bullying or years of not feeling seen. If the exercise brings up a lot, stop, ground yourself, and consider working with a therapist.
In IFS therapy, we get to know protector parts with their permission, and only work with the hurt underneath when your system is ready. You can learn more about the approach from the IFS Institute, or in my plain-English guide to IFS therapy.
Read more about online IFS therapy, or about what causes imposter syndrome.
Sources and further reading
- IFS Institute: about IFS and finding a therapist
- Shadick, N. A. et al. (2013). A randomized controlled trial of an IFS-based psychotherapeutic intervention on outcomes in rheumatoid arthritis. The Journal of Rheumatology, 40(11), 1831 to 1841.
- Kohli, S. K. (2024). But What Will People Say? Navigating Mental Health, Identity, Love and Family Between Cultures. Review at Health Collective.
If you’re in crisis or worried about your safety, call 999, NHS 111 (option 2) or Samaritans on 116 123.
About Dr Gurpreet Kaur
Clinical Psychologist (HCPC registered), EMDR and IFS practitioner. 25+ years in mental health, 15+ as a Clinical Psychologist. I work online with adults across the UK, including people carrying hidden hurts behind a capable life.
Free workbook
Why you understand your patterns but still can’t change them
Not ready to book yet?
Get my free 21-page workbook, with exercises to map a pattern and understand the parts behind it.
Sent straight to your inbox.
Related reading


